PDA

View Full Version : Replaygain scanner not working?



tm1969
January 21st, 2018, 09:35 PM
I am using a Samsung Galaxy Sky with Android version 6.0.1. I have tried at least eight times to use the Replaygain Scanner in the Foobar Mobile app for Android to standardize the volumes of my music (which is all on the SD card); each time it scans the entire library (over 3,000 songs), yet each time nothing changes; all my music sounds just like it did before I ran the scanner. After the most recent attempt (yesterday), I started poking around and looked under Tools/Console; there I found a huge number of tracks listed. Each one said the same thing: "could not update tags on file [name of file/track]...reason: access denied".
I would really like to get my music volumes adjusted so I don't have the volumes all over the place. Any advice on what I might be doing wrong or overlooking?

Terry
February 10th, 2018, 04:27 PM
Don't know enough about Android OS to advise as to why App is having permission issues.
OTOH, this is quite an intensive chore for a phone battery to manage. You might consider having the Foobar200 desktop app or any other replay gain aware desktop app do the scanning.
Trivial and fast.

EpicForever
February 28th, 2018, 08:18 AM
@Terry: Lol. I will translate your answer:
"If you have a mobile app which lists certain capability/functionality as available, better not use it an use some desktop app instead to perform any needed action".
Great advice. You know, I am at the moment in the hospital (seriously). Music from the phone is my salvation. And guess what - I don't have here any desktop type device to run Win32 foobar there, to scan files that I recently purchased at Google Play! How this could happen?
But telling this us not why I came here. I came here to say:

Dear god, sweet Jesus. One app, so many bugs. REPLAYGAIN SCANNER IN FOOBAR MOBILE FOR ANDROID IS FAULTY! Foobar detects files requiring scan, performs it, says it saved results (by not showing list if files with missing RG info) but VOLUME IS NOT CHANGING AT ALL! Loudness war sausages are as loud as they were before scan. There are no errors in Console.

Foobar mobile: 1.0.94 ARM 32bit
Phone: D6633
Android : 6.0.1 (security patch level: 1st May 2016 - there are no updates available, even security ones)

EpicForever
April 19th, 2018, 10:56 AM
@Peter: Is there anything done towards this problem?

EpicForever
May 10th, 2018, 02:45 AM
Problem persists in v. 1.1.13. Plus attempt to save scan results to tags again ends up with "access denied" errors.
And by the way - seems foobar mobile respects iTunes Soundcheck without option to disable it. I purchased some file but haven't RG scanned it in Win32 foobar. Still file is not listed as missing RG info in Android's foobar mobile.

Phone: the same D6633 with Android 6.0.1

Mynameislol
June 14th, 2018, 09:37 AM
Did you manage to get it working? I'm on a galaxy S8, and I'm having the exact same issues as you. I think Root might be a solution, but I would only do it as a last resort.

Mynameislol
June 27th, 2018, 07:23 AM
Installed version 1.0.94, everything works perfectly now

Mynameislol
June 27th, 2018, 09:32 AM
Alright, it appears that older versions can save replaygain tags, but ONLY on internal storage, while the newest version can't save to either.

Why is there not a single app besides foobar2000 that has a replaygain scanning function?

I've been searching for one for years and the only one that exists is broken

Secone00
July 9th, 2018, 01:29 PM
I also ran into these problems mentioned with the Android app, but was just now able to get around them.

After letting it automatically scan for your music folder, I instead went to the media library options; removed the "Music on Internal Storage" folder it had automatically found, use the "Enter path manually..." button, then selected "Launch system folder picker", clicked on my device name, THEN selected the folder my music was in, I was able to write all the replay gain values to my songs. Hope this helps anyone else getting frustrated.

Mynameislol
July 10th, 2018, 10:05 AM
I also ran into these problems mentioned with the Android app, but was just now able to get around them.

After letting it automatically scan for your music folder, I instead went to the media library options; removed the "Music on Internal Storage" folder it had automatically found, use the "Enter path manually..." button, then selected "Launch system folder picker", clicked on my device name, THEN selected the folder my music was in, I was able to write all the replay gain values to my songs. Hope this helps anyone else getting frustrated.

Confirmed! This works on both internal & microsd!
Now I can FINNALLY listen to music in my car!

DarkVoyage
July 12th, 2018, 06:15 PM
Yes, it works. Thanks for the advice. This is Android problem actually and the writing permission is almost always given like that - by selecting the folder in system picker, if available. The realisation in foobar2000 is not obvious though.